Imagine this: You’ve just launched a brilliant new product, and customers are loving it. Sales are climbing, and your brand is gaining recognition. But then, out of nowhere, you receive a legal notice claiming patent infringement. Panic sets in. What went wrong? How to know if you are infringing on a patent? How can you be sure your innovation doesn’t step on someone else’s patent rights?
If you’re a business owner or an entrepreneur with a fresh idea, understanding how to check patent infringement risk is crucial. Ignoring it can lead to expensive lawsuits, financial loss, and even the shutdown of your business. Let’s dive into the ways to determine patent infringement risk and ensure your venture is legally safe.
Table of Contents
What Is Patent Infringement?
Patent infringement happens when someone makes, uses, or sells a patented invention without the patent owner’s permission. This can occur knowingly or unknowingly, but either way, the consequences can be severe.
That’s why business owners must learn how to check for patent infringement before launching a product or service.
What Constitutes Patent Infringement?

Patent infringement—it’s a fascinating and complex topic. So, what exactly does it mean? Well, it occurs when someone makes, uses, sells, or imports a patented invention without permission. But how do we prove it? Here are the key elements to prove patent infringement
- Ownership: First things first, the plaintiff must own a valid patent. Without this, there’s no case!
- Infringement: The defendant has to have performed an unauthorized act involving the patented invention. Did they make it, use it, or sell it without a license?
- Claims Comparison: Here’s where it gets interesting. The plaintiff must show that the defendant’s product or process includes each and every element of at least one patent claim. It’s like matching puzzle pieces!
- Jurisdiction: The infringement must occur within the jurisdiction where the patent is valid. Patents aren’t universal, so this is crucial.
These elements help ensure that the patent holder’s rights are protected and that any unauthorized use is properly addressed.
Types of Patent Infringement Explained with Landmark Cases

Infringement can take many forms. Here’s a breakdown of the most common types:
1. Direct Infringement
Occurs when a product or process directly violates a patent without authorization. Example: Manufacturing and selling a patented product without permission.
Landmark Case: Cornell University v. Hewlett-Packard Co. (2009) – HP was found liable for selling systems with patented technology.
2. Indirect Infringement
Occurs when someone induces or contributes to another party’s patent infringement. Types:
Induced Infringement: Persuading or aiding another to infringe.
Contributory Infringement: Supplying a component with no non-infringing use. Example: Supplying specialized components for a patented process.
Landmark Case: Global-Tech Appliances, Inc. v. SEB S.A. (2011) – Global-Tech was found guilty of induced infringement.
3. Literal Infringement
Occurs when an accused product matches every element of a patent claim. Example: A device with components exactly as described in a patent.
Landmark Case: Polaroid Corp. v. Eastman Kodak Co. (1977) – Kodak’s cameras infringed Polaroid’s patents.
4. Infringement by Doctrine of Equivalents
Occurs when a product performs the same function in the same way to achieve the same result as a patented invention. Example: Modifying a component but retaining the same function.
Landmark Case: Graver Tank & Manufacturing Co. v. Linde Air Products Co. (1950) – Substitution of manganese for magnesium still infringed the patent.
5. Willful Infringement
Occurs when someone knowingly copies a patented invention without permission. Example: Copying a patented smartphone screen design knowingly.
Landmark Case: Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc. (2016) – Easier compensation for patent holders when willful infringement is proven.
6. Indirect Patent Infringement by Importation
Occurs when someone imports a product knowing it will be used to infringe a patent. Example: Importing a component to be combined with others to create an infringing product.
Landmark Case: Comcast Corp. v. ITC and Rovi Corp. (2020) – Importing articles that infringe later still counts as infringement.
7. Design Patent Infringement
Occurs when someone copies the unique appearance of a patented design. Key Points: Ordinary Observer Test and Point of Novelty. Example: Copying the design of an iPhone. Landmark Case: Samsung Electronics Co. v. Apple Inc. (2016) – Samsung held responsible for copying iPhone design.
Why Should Business Owners Care About Patent Infringement?
Avoid Legal Trouble – Patent lawsuits are costly and time-consuming.
Protect Your Investment – A lawsuit could force you to stop selling your product.
Stay Competitive – Knowing your legal standing prevents setbacks.
Build Credibility – Being compliant shows customers and investors you’re a trustworthy brand.
Now, let’s explore how to determine if your business idea or product is at risk of infringing on a patent.
Ways to Identify Patent Infringement Risk

Here’s the million-dollar question. How can you be sure you’re not stepping on someone else’s intellectual property?
Ways to Identify Patent Infringement
1. Conduct a Patent Search:
Conduct a thorough search to identify existing patents that are similar to your product or process. Use patent databases like Google Patents or the USPTO website.
2. Analyze Patent Claims:
Carefully review the claims of the identified patents. Compare each element of your product or process to the patent claims.
3. Differences in Elements:
Ensure that your product or process does not include each and every element of the patent claims. Even a small difference can be crucial.
4. Doctrine of Equivalents:
Consider whether your product or process performs substantially the same function in substantially the same way to achieve substantially the same result as the patented invention. If it does, it might still be considered an infringement.
5. Legal Advice:
Consult a patent attorney to get a professional opinion. They can help you interpret the claims and assess potential infringement risks.
6. Design-Around Strategy:
If your product is close to infringing, consider redesigning it to avoid the patented elements.
7. Request a Freedom-to-Operate (FTO) Analysis:
Conduct an FTO analysis to evaluate whether your invention can be commercialized without infringing on existing patents.
How to Avoid Patent Infringement Lawsuit

Prevention is better than cure. Here are some foolproof ways to avoid infringement:
1. Conduct Thorough Patent Searches
Before you introduce any new product or technology, it’s essential to conduct a comprehensive patent search. This allows you to assess whether a similar patent already exists. You can use public patent databases such as:
- Google Patents
- USPTO Database
- WIPO’s Global Patent Search
A patent search helps to avoid costly legal mistakes and allows you to determine if a product you want to develop could infringe an existing patent.
Example: If you’re a tech startup creating a new mobile application, performing a patent search might reveal that a competitor already holds a patent for similar functionality. In that case, you may need to alter your design to avoid infringement.
2. Analyze Existing Patents Carefully
Once you’ve found relevant patents, carefully read and analyze their claims. Patent claims are the most important part of the patent because they define the scope of the protection. The patent’s claims specify what aspects of an invention are protected, and you’ll need to ensure that your product doesn’t overlap with these claims.
3. Seek Legal Advice from a Patent Attorney
A patent attorney can guide you through the complexities of patent law and help ensure your designs and products don’t infringe on others’ intellectual property. They can also provide advice on whether it’s worth applying for your own patent, which could protect your inventions and give you the rights to prevent others from copying them.
4. License Patented Technologies
If you discover that a product or technology you’re interested in using is patented, you can negotiate a licensing agreement with the patent holder. A licensing agreement allows you to legally use the patented technology for a fee, avoiding the risk of infringement.
Example: If you want to integrate a patented software solution into your app, consider negotiating a licensing deal with the patent holder rather than attempting to create a similar feature on your own.
5. Make Your Own Innovations
If you’re in an industry that relies heavily on technology or design, innovation is key. Patents are granted to new and useful inventions, so if you create something unique, you can secure your own patent rights. This will protect your intellectual property and give you an edge over your competitors.
6. Regularly Monitor Patent Activity
Stay updated on the latest patent filings in your industry. This will help you understand emerging trends and identify any potential risks of infringement. Monitoring patent activity also ensures that you’re aware of new patents that could impact your product lines.
How Much Does Patent Infringement Cost?
Patent infringement isn’t just a legal headache; it’s also a financial burden.
Costs Associated with Infringement
1. Claim Construction Costs (Markman Hearing):
- Less than $1 million at risk: Between $250,000.
- $25 million or more at risk: Up to $2.375 million.
2. Total Trial Costs:
- Lower-stakes cases: From $700,000.
- High-value cases: Over $4 million.
3. Median Litigation Costs:
$1 million to $10 million at stake: Median cost was $1.7 million in 2017, showing a significant drop from 2015.
4. Costs for Lower Stakes:
Worth less than $1 million: Median legal costs are around $650,000.
5. Average Cost for Mid-Range Stakes:
$1 million to $25 million at stake: The average cost to go through trial is about $2.8 million.
6. IPR or Post-Grant Review Costs:
Inter Partes Review (IPR) or Post-Grant Review: Costs range from $120,000 to $400,000, depending on the stage of the process.
In short, the higher the financial stakes, the more expensive the litigation process becomes, especially when considering the costs associated with gathering evidence and seeing the case through to a final decision.
Example: In the Apple v. Samsung (2016) case, Samsung was ordered to pay $399 million in damages for infringing on Apple’s design patents.
What If You Accidentally Infringe on a Patent?

If you discover that you’ve infringed on a patent, don’t panic. Here’s what to do:
Consult a Patent Lawyer –
They will assess the situation and offer the best course of action.
Negotiate with the Patent Owner –
You may be able to settle through licensing or a business agreement.
Redesign Your Product –
If possible, modify your product to avoid infringement.
Prepare a Legal Defense –
If sued, work with legal experts to fight the claim or reach a settlement.
Conclusion
Checking for patent infringement isn’t just for big corporations—it’s essential for small business owners, startups, and entrepreneurs too. By understanding how to check patent infringement risk, using patent infringement detection methods, and following a patent infringement risk assessment guide, you can launch your business with confidence.
Innovation is exciting, but legal troubles are not. Take the time to research, seek legal guidance, and ensure your product is patent-safe. That way, you can focus on growing your business without the fear of lawsuits.
Do you need expert help with patent searches and legal advice? Consult a patent attorney today and secure your business’s future!
Disclaimer: This article is based on thorough research and the author’s expertise. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the information provided, it is not intended to substitute for professional legal advice. The author is not liable for any reliance on this information. For specific legal concerns, please seek professional counsel.